Heretics, Schismatics, or Catholics? Latin Attitudes to the Greeks in the Long Twelfth Century
SAVVAS NEOCLEOUS
WhileabookonpoliticalanddiplomaticrelationsbetweentheByzantineEmpire
andtheLatinworldmightperhapsrequirejustificationorevenapology,asimilarexplanationforastudyof theLatinperceptionsofandattitudestowardthe
ByzantineEmpireintermsof religionwouldseemincongruousor,atbest,superfluous.Historiansconcurthatthepoliticaldivisionof theRomanworldintoLatin
WesternandGreekEasternRomanEmpiresattheendof thefourthcenturyled
toafundamentalanddeep-rooteddivergencebetweenthem.Accordingtothe
deeplyentrenchedbeliefthathasprevailedinmodernacademic,educational,
andpopularliterature,butwhichhasremainedlargelyunexamined,theresulting
religiousandculturalantagonismbetweenthetwopartsofmedievalChristen
domeventuallyproducedthe“schismof1054.”Lessthanfiftyyearsafter,Greeks
andLatinscameintoclosercontactasaresultof thecrusades:theencounterwas
disastrous,leadingtothecaptureandsackofConstantinoplein1204bythe
armiesoftheFourthCrusade.
Certainly,thisviewwasacommonplaceinuniversitytextbookswhenIwas
anundergraduatestudent.ButthesubjectofLatin-Greekrelationsfascinated
me,andIcontinuedtoexplorethetopicfurther.Asagraduatestudent,Iacquired
greaterfamiliarity withtheprimarysources,allthewhiletryingtointerpretthem
withintheintellectualframeworkIhadinherited.Itwasatthisstage,however,
thatIdiscoveredthatonlycertaintextsconformedtotheselong-established
views;othersrevealedaverydifferentpictureofLatinperceptionsofandattitudestowardtheGreeksintermsofreligion,andrequiredmorecareful,independent,andrigorousanalysis.Thiswork,whichbeganasalongresearcharticle
butrapidlyexpandedtoitscurrentsizewhenitbecameevidentthatonlyamore
extendedstudycoulddojusticetothewealthofevidenceIhaduncovered,isthe
result.
…
andtheLatinworldmightperhapsrequirejustificationorevenapology,asimilarexplanationforastudyof theLatinperceptionsofandattitudestowardthe
ByzantineEmpireintermsof religionwouldseemincongruousor,atbest,superfluous.Historiansconcurthatthepoliticaldivisionof theRomanworldintoLatin
WesternandGreekEasternRomanEmpiresattheendof thefourthcenturyled
toafundamentalanddeep-rooteddivergencebetweenthem.Accordingtothe
deeplyentrenchedbeliefthathasprevailedinmodernacademic,educational,
andpopularliterature,butwhichhasremainedlargelyunexamined,theresulting
religiousandculturalantagonismbetweenthetwopartsofmedievalChristen
domeventuallyproducedthe“schismof1054.”Lessthanfiftyyearsafter,Greeks
andLatinscameintoclosercontactasaresultof thecrusades:theencounterwas
disastrous,leadingtothecaptureandsackofConstantinoplein1204bythe
armiesoftheFourthCrusade.
Certainly,thisviewwasacommonplaceinuniversitytextbookswhenIwas
anundergraduatestudent.ButthesubjectofLatin-Greekrelationsfascinated
me,andIcontinuedtoexplorethetopicfurther.Asagraduatestudent,Iacquired
greaterfamiliarity withtheprimarysources,allthewhiletryingtointerpretthem
withintheintellectualframeworkIhadinherited.Itwasatthisstage,however,
thatIdiscoveredthatonlycertaintextsconformedtotheselong-established
views;othersrevealedaverydifferentpictureofLatinperceptionsofandattitudestowardtheGreeksintermsofreligion,andrequiredmorecareful,independent,andrigorousanalysis.Thiswork,whichbeganasalongresearcharticle
butrapidlyexpandedtoitscurrentsizewhenitbecameevidentthatonlyamore
extendedstudycoulddojusticetothewealthofevidenceIhaduncovered,isthe
result.
…
年:
2019
出版社:
Pontifical Institute of Mediaeval Studies
语言:
english
页:
300
文件:
PDF, 164.53 MB
IPFS:
,
english, 2019